It's a little difficult
to review this one because while it does take place during WWII and the
author was Jewish, ultimately it is a teenager's diary. Which means
endless entries about boys and friendship drama. I felt really bad while
reading this because it was hopelessly banal and I found Renia to be
*slightly* annoying and shallow and it made me feel really guilty because of
knowing her fate.
For most of the book there is almost no mention of
anything happening outside of her boyfriend and friend groups, maybe it
was a form of escapism, or maybe she was just an oblivious teenager in
love. I can't say that if I opened my niece's diary that it would be filled
with anything of substance either. And that in itself is why I continued
to read this one even though it wasn't enjoyable. Because unbeknownst
to Renia, these daily recaps and poems would be her only legacy and when
it comes to Holocaust stories we tend to deify the person for what
became of them, and to forget that they were once just ordinary people
like you and I and deserve to be remembered as such. Yes many of them
did extraordinary things in times of necessity, but for the most part
they were mothers, daughters, fathers and sons leading regular lives
until someone decided that their mere existence was affronting. These
people were more than their circumstances and we owe it to them to
remember that.
After the abrupt ending of Renia's diary (and her
life), perfectly punctuated by the shot that killed her, we get a few
entries from her beloved Zygu himself. I will say I *loathed* his
treatment of her over the entirety of her diary, he was selfish and
insulting and just not the best person it seemed, but he proved his
worth in the end. Like I said, extraordinary in the time of necessity.
Renia's sister Elizabeth/Ariana's notes added a lot of depth to this
book, as well as much needed background information. I wish that they
would consider adding a list of names/terms to the front of the book to
help clear up some confusion as to who shes referencing in her entries.
Especially with her parents names, I think it would have been helpful to
have that information up front because she would often say Bulus and
Mommy together like they were separate people. I do wonder too how Renia
would have felt knowing people would be reading her most intimate
thoughts, especially after how she reacts to Zygu doing so.
Thanks to Netgalley and the Publisher for providing me with a copy of this book to review. All opinions are my own.
No comments:
Post a Comment